1955 – 1969
Father Michael A. Nugent*
1969 – 1992
Father Donald C. Schulz*
1977 – 1978
Father Charles Jackson* Co-Pastor
1992 – 1997
Father Frank Lane
1997 – 1998
Father J. Colby Grimes*
1998 – 2000
Father Jerome P. Rodenfels
2000 – 2013
Father Michael B. Watson
*Deceased