1958 – 1959
Father Ambrose Metzger*
1959 – 1960
Father Lawrence O’Connor*
1960 – 1965
Father Paul Laurinaitis
1965 – 1972
Father William DeVille
1972 – 1975
Father Luciana Farina
1975 – 1977
Father Jerome Rodenfels
1978 – 1979
Father John Dittoe*
1979 – 1982
Father Jack Maynard
1982 – 1986
Father William DeVille
1986 – 1990
Father Patrick Rogers
1990 – 1994
Father Michael Watson
1992 – 1994
Father Dennis Stevenson
1994 – 1998
Father Thomas Buffer
1998 – 2002
Father Kenneth Anderson
2001 – 2005
Father Anthony Dinovo, Jr.
2005 – 2007
Father Steven Seever
2007 – 2009
Father Joseph Yokum
2010 – 2012
Father Tyron Tomson
2013 – 2015
Father Nicholas Droll
2015 – 2018
Father Tony Davis
2018 - 2020
Father T.J. Lehigh
*Deceased